How to Silence the Inner Critic and Make Confident Decisions
"You've been criticizing yourself for years, and it hasn't worked. Try approving of yourself and see what happens." — Louise Hay
What's the Inner Critic, anyways
There's an annoying voice in your head constantly questioning your every move, analyzing every potential outcome, and reminding you of past mistakes. That's the inner critic, who happens to be a relentless companion that feeds off self-doubt and thrives on perfectionism. At its core, the inner critic is conceived from self-judgment. It highlights every flaw, and every imperfection, dragging us into a cycle of exhaustion, frustration, and despair. It's as though trusting yourself becomes an impossible task.
But here's the truth: this voice isn’t who you are, and you have the power to change the story.
Where Did the Inner Critic Come From?
Childhood Experiences
Our inner critic is often shaped by voices from our past—parents, teachers, or authority figures whose words we internalized. When we were told we weren't enough or compared to others, we began to believe it. These early experiences can leave scars that linger into adulthood, distorting how we see ourselves.
Social Conditioning
Society sets impossible standards. We're told to conform, to fit in, and to meet expectations. Growing up, I remember how badly I wanted to belong. The pressure to adapt—to be perfect—only amplified the inner critic's voice, pushing me to question whether I was ever truly "enough."
Fear of Rejection or Failure
This is the inner critic's favorite weapon: fear. It whispers, "Don't take that risk. What if you fail? What if they reject you?" It convinces us that playing it safe is the only way to avoid hurt, but in doing so, it keeps us from fully living.
Trauma or Negative Reinforcement
Trauma leaves deep imprints on our psyche. Verbal abuse, neglect, or abandonment only strengthen the inner critic's grip. Its harsh voice mirrors the pain of those experiences, shaping how we see ourselves and connect with others.
Evolutionary Roots
On a primal level, the inner critic is linked to our brain's fight-or-flight response. It's a survival mechanism designed to protect us from perceived threats. But in modern life, this protective instinct often goes into overdrive, leading to unnecessary self-criticism and impacting our wellbeing.
What's the Purpose of the Inner Critic?
Oddly enough, the inner critic often thinks it's helping. It may:
• Protect from Failure: Criticizing us to prevent potential mistakes.
• Encourage Growth: Pushing us to improve by pointing out flaws.
• Ensure Social Belonging: Warning us to conform to avoid rejection.
However, unchecked can become overbearing, damaging self-esteem and hindering our ability to move forward.
How to Quiet and Reframe the Inner Critic
- Cultivate Awareness
Recognize when the inner critic speaks. Notice its patterns and triggers.
- Challenge the Narrative
Ask yourself: "Is this thought true? Is it helpful?" Often, you'll find it's neither.
- Speak with Compassion
Treat yourself like you would a dear friend. Replace harsh criticism with kind, supportive words.
- Revisit the Past
Reflect on where this voice came from. Release outdated beliefs that no longer serve you.
- Practice Self-Affirmation
Build a habit of affirming your strengths. Remind yourself of your worth regularly and unapologetically.
The inner critic doesn't define you—it's a learned voice, and with effort, it can be transformed into a supportive inner coach that fosters growth and confidence.
Notable Statistics
Prevalence of Impostor Phenomenon
• Up to 82% of people experience impostor feelings at some point in their lives, often tied to the "inner critic," amplifying self-doubt and fear of being exposed as a fraud (American Psychological Association, 2021).
Burnout and Work-Related Stress
• Nearly 3 in 5 employees (59%) report experiencing negative impacts of work-related stress, including feelings of self-doubt, reduced motivation, and lack of energy—factors often linked to the inner critic (American Psychological Association, 2022).
Impact of Self-Criticism on Mental Health
• Self-criticism is a known contributor to increased anxiety, depression, and burnout in professional settings. These conditions can significantly hinder workplace performance and overall well-being (Shahar, Britton, Sbarra, Figueredo, & Bootzin, 2012).
PS...If you're enjoying The Empowered Leader Newsletter, please share it with a friend. Together, we can build a stronger community of technical leaders.
And whenever you're ready, here's how I can help you:
Book a free 30-minute coaching session to work through your inner critic dialogue.
Thanks, Margaret, for this comprehensive share about the inner critic.
It seems to be quite prevalent in so many of our lives, especially us overachieving types :)
Getting a handle on the 'voice in our head' is g game changer and long ago I learned a slightly radical approach to it : acceptance! Accept this inner critic , honor it, rather than trying to push it away.
After all, it's been trying to keep us safe all these years.
Much more to say about it, another time.
Thanks for bringing up this important and impactful topic.
This is so profound. For me, it was mostly fear of failure, until I learnt to embrace "the minimum courage formula:" In essence, what is that one tiny thing I can do right now, despite being afraid? And this has kept me going.